Hello dear
Welcome To Picky Barista
At Picky Barista, nestled in the heart of New York, we offer more than just coffee; we craft experiences. Our journey began with a passion for high-quality ingredients and the love for creating delightful breakfast choices. From our organic avocado toast to homemade pastries like the beloved apple cake, every item embodies a commitment to flavor and freshness. Customers rave about our perfectly brewed Stumptown coffee and cozy atmosphere, reflecting a neighborhood gem feel. Our friendly staff, led by a devoted owner, ensures that every visit is memorable. Join us to savor delicious bites and a warm community spirit!
Taste the best
Discover Our Menu
ORGANIC AVOCADO TOAST WITH TOMATO, FETA, SPICES
US$8.75WALNUT CRANBERRY CHIP COOKIE
US$3.75VANILLA COOKIE
US$1.00
SPINACH AND CHEESE BUREK
US$8.25SESAME CHEESE ROLL
US$3.75ORGANIC BLUEBERRY CAKE
US$5.50
ORGANIC APPLE CAKE
US$5.50GLUTEN-FREE BANANA BREAD
US$6.00FETA BUREK
US$8.25 About
Picky Barista
Welcome to Picky Barista, a hidden gem tucked away in the vibrant neighborhood of Morningside Heights, New York. Located at 2680 Broadway, this delightful café offers more than just a caffeine fix. With a focus on quality and a passion for handcrafted food, Picky Barista elevates your coffee experience while ensuring each bite is just as memorable.
As soon as you enter, the inviting atmosphere and friendly staff make you feel at home. Guests have praised the warmth and professionalism of the team—something that sets this café apart. Customer Yuna Z describes it perfectly as “a cute neighborhood cafe” that draws you in.
The menu features an all-day breakfast selection that emphasizes fresh, organic ingredients. Highlights include:
- Organic Avocado Toast topped with tomatoes, feta, and spices for only $8.75.
- Egg and Cheese Croissant Sandwich with pesto—an irresistible starter at $8.25.
- Prosciutto, Mozzarella, and Pesto Sandwich that’s a must-try for $8.75.
- Overnight Oats with chia seeds, almond butter, and honey for a healthy start at $7.75.
For those with a sweet tooth, don’t miss out on their homemade pastries. Each bite is a testament to the skill and dedication poured into the recipes. Minnie Sinthuchai perfectly encapsulated this notion, recommending the Avocado Toast and Cinnamon Roll as standout dishes that are “so, so delicious!” Here are some highlight sweets:
- Apple Cake using Mama’s recipe, rich and moist, at $5.50.
- Balkan Croissant with Jam, a delightful treat for $3.75.
- Blueberry Cake for $5.50 that strikes the perfect balance between tart and sweet.
- Chocolate Chip Cookie that melts in your mouth, a perfect companion to their coffee.
Speaking of coffee, Picky Barista partners with Stumptown Coffee, helping facilitate a robust and flavourful brew that has been praised for its smoothness and non-acidic blend. Arri, another satisfied customer, enthused about their drip coffee and espresso, noting that they both offer delicious flavor profiles. With options for different milk and convenient tap payment, you won’t leave empty-handed or dissatisfied.
As the seasons change, so do the specials, enhancing your visit. Rebecca Durance Hine’s experience with the caramel apple chai cider exemplifies the café’s creativity and commitment to seasonal offerings.
Lastly, Picky Barista’s commitment to customer service shines through, as highlighted by Ana Roman’s review—where the staff swiftly addressed an accidental mix-up with drinks. This level of attentiveness ensures that every customer leaves not just satisfied but eager to return.
In summary, Picky Barista is more than just a café; it is a community hub that marries exquisite food with an exceptional coffee experience. If you find yourself near Broadway, do not miss the opportunity to indulge in culinary delights that will have you raving long after you've left.
People talk
Our Guestbook
“ This place is a gem!! Very cute neighborhood cafe ”
“ Great Late art and much better Coffee! Stumptown coffee is really tasty, plus they have homemade pastries and Breakfast menu! Must try Avocado Toast and Cinnamon Roll, it’s so so delicious! All recommendations, also I had a opportunity to meet the owner, he is so kind and professional! ”
“ Cute little spot with tasty homemade pastries. I got their drip coffee and my partner got an espresso and both are delicious. My drip coffee was smooth and strong and not too acidic. They have post milk and accept tap to pay, too. I tried their baklava which was a nice nosh. ”
“ Cute little coffee shop with friendly staff and very tasty drinks! Their latte is delicious and the seasonal drink specials are fun. I had a caramel apple chai cider in November that was soo good. The service is quick and they definitely take care of the customers. My friend's drink got taken by another customer by accident and they gave her another one right away. Definitely recommend! ”
“ Great experience at Peaky Barista. Professional and friendly service, delicious food and good coffee/lattes. Roberta was very kind and attentive while attending everyone in the shop. Will visit again. Thank you ”
“ This charming coffee shop tucked away in the bustling streets of NYC, has quickly become my favorite spot for a delightful caffeine fix. What sets this place apart is not just the quality of their coffee but the personal touch that comes with every cup. The owner, a passionate and experienced coffee enthusiast, takes the time to engage with customers, ensuring a personalized experience that goes beyond your average coffee shop. Whether you're a latte lover or an espresso aficionado, there's something for every palate. Pastries perfectly complement the rich brews. What truly makes this small business stand out is its sense of community. If you're in the mood for a genuine coffee experience in the heart of the city, look no further – this hidden gem is a must-visit! ”
“ Best comfy & cozy place in town to have a coffee or breakfast, great food & staff is always welcoming Love Dragan the owner & his family is always around making the atmosphere even better ”
“ Great local coffee shop location on 102nd and Broadway! Matcha and tumeric lattes are delicious and well made without any added sugars. Balkan coffee packs a punch and is delicious. I had the Nutella Roll, highly recommended! All of the pastries are made in house fresh each day. Definitely try them! Decor is welcoming and stylized. Small place to sit and enjoy. You can even pick up one of the books to read if you’d like. Staff is great; specifically, George and Sea, who are both knowledgeable, efficient, and helpful. Nice local spot in the early morning for a coffee and freshly made (and tasty) pastry! Definitely a must-try in the Upper West Side. ”